Jahr	Nominiert für	Preis	Ergebnis
2014	Tegan and Sara	Canadian Radio Music Awards, Fans' Choice	Nominiert
2014	"Closer"	Canadian Radio Music Awards, SOCAN Song of the Year	Nominiert
2014	Tegan and Sara	Canadian Radio Music Awards, Best New Group/Solo Artist - Mainstream AC	Gewonnen
2014	Tegan and Sara	Juno Awards, Songwriter of the Year	Nominiert
2014	"Closer"	Juno Awards, Single of the Year	Gewonnen
2014	Tegan and Sara	Juno Awards, Group of the Year	Gewonnen
2014	Heartthrob	Juno Awards, Pop Album of the Year	Gewonnen
2014	Tegan and Sara	GLAAD Media Awards Outstanding Music Artist	Gewonnen
2013	Tegan and Sara	MTV Europe Music Awards Best Canadian Act	Nominiert
2013	Heartthrob	2013 Polaris Music Prize Shortlist	Nominiert
2013	"Closer"	Much Music Video Awards, International Video Of The Year By A Canadian	Nominiert
2013	"Closer"	Canadian Radio Music Awards, Best New Group - Dance/Urban/Rhythmic	Gewonnen
2013	"Closer"	NewNowNext Awards, That's My Jam	Nominiert
2013	"Body Work"	MTV Woodie Awards, Tag Team Woodie	Nominiert
2013	Get Along	Grammy Awards, Best Long Form Music Video	Nominiert
2012	Get Along	Juno Awards, Music DVD of the Year	Nominiert
2011	Tegan and Sara	Indie Awards, Group or Duo of the Year	Nominiert
2010	Tegan and Sara	Western Canadian Music Awards, International Achievement Award	Gewonnen
2010	Sainthood	Polaris Music Prize	Nominiert
2010	Sainthood	Juno Awards, Alternative Album of the Year	Nominiert
2009	Song "The Con"	Studio8 Song of August 2009	Gewonnen
2008	The Con	Juno Awards, Alternative Album of the Year	Nominiert
2007	It's Not Fun Don't Do It	Juno Awards, Music DVD of the Year	Nominiert
2006	So Jealous	Juno Awards, Alternative Album of the Year	Nominiert
2003	If It Was You	Western Canadian Music Awards, Outstanding Pop Recording	Gewonnen
2000	Tegan and Sara	YTV Band/Musical Group Achievement Award	Gewonnen